All submitted manuscripts shall be examined by at least three experts in the corresponding field. However, the examination of manuscripts or news briefs requested from the academic society may be exempted. If a revision is needed after reviewing the organization of papers by the Editorial Board, the revision may be requested.
The most three suitable examiners are appointed according to the paper subject among the editors. However, if suitable examiners to be appointed are not found among the editors, external examiner(s) may be appointed according to the decision by the Editorial Board.
No. | Examiner A | Examiner B | Examiner C | Initial decision | Decision after re-examination |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Publication | Publication | Publication after revision |
Publication | - |
2 | Publication | Publication | Re-examination after revision |
Publication | - |
3 | Publication | Publication | No publication | Publication | - |
4 | Publication | Publication after revision |
Publication after revision |
Publication after revision |
- |
5 | Publication | Publication after revision |
Re-examination after revision |
Publication after revision |
- |
6 | Publication | Publication after revision |
No publication | Publication after revision |
- |
7 | Publication after revision |
Publication after revision |
Re-examination after revision |
Publication after revision |
- |
8 | Publication after revision |
Publication after revision |
No publication | Publication after revision |
- |
9 | Publication | Re-examination after revision |
Re-examination after revision |
Re-examination after revision (B,C) |
Publication if one of Examiner B or C decided publication |
10 | Publication | Re-examination after revision |
No publication | Re-examination after revision (B) |
Publication if Examiner B decided publication |
11 | Publication after revision |
Re-examination after revision |
Re-examination after revision |
Re-examination after revision (B,C) |
Publication if one or two of Examiners B and C decided publication |
10 | Publication | Re-examination after revision |
No publication | Re-examination after revision (B,C) |
B 위원이 게재판정한 경우 게재 |
13 | Re-examination after revision |
Re-examination after revision |
Re-examination after revision |
Re-examination after revision (A,B,C) |
Publication if two or three of Examiners A, B, and C decided publication |
14 | Re-examination after revision |
Re-examination after revision |
No publication | Re-examination after revision (A,B) |
Publication if both of Examiners A and B decided publication |
15 | Publication | No publication | No publication | No publication | - |
16 | Publication after revision |
No publication | No publication | No publication | - |
17 | Re-examination after revision |
No publication | No publication | No publication | - |
This regulation is effective from the date of resolution at the General Meeting after approval by the Board of Directors on May 11, 2013.